Featured Post

So It Begins, Part 9: Eomer's Return

  Good morning gamers, This is a scenario we did in Fantasy Fellowships and if I'm honest, this is one of the least balanced scenarios i...

Thursday, November 19, 2026

So It Begins, Part 9: Eomer's Return

 Good morning gamers,

This is a scenario we did in Fantasy Fellowships and if I'm honest, this is one of the least balanced scenarios in the pack. There are WAY more Rohan assets than there should be and no equalizer for the Uruk-Hai. So today, we're going to play to the normal victory conditions, but we'll be doing it with Matched Play forces of 600 points.

Eomer's Return (War in Rohan, p. 40)

And here are the lists, not split by warband:

  • Forces of Good: The Riders of Eomer 
    • Eomer, Marshal of the Riddermark with everything 
    • Gandalf the White on Shadowfax
    • 9 Riders of Rohan 
    • 4 Riders of Rohan with throwing spears
    • 1 Rider of Rohan with banner 
  • Forces of Evil: The Assault Upon Helm's Deep 
    • 5 Uruk-Hai Captains
    • 23 Uruk-Hai Warriors with shields
    • 18 Uruk-Hai Warriors with pikes
    • 1 Uruk-Hai Warrior with banner 

Centaur said that he forsook the crossbows because, "They didn't have them at that part of the film." I for one am grateful that I don't have to try to get Blinding Light up each turn, so I won't complain. The pikes are my big fear - they're the force multiplier and can make everything go wrong very quickly.

The board is a 24"x48" setup - it's wide open, but half the size of a normal Matched Play game:


Turn 1: Priority Good


Gandalf cast Terrifying Aura on himself (free Will). Both sides advance and that's about it.

Turn 2: Priority Evil


Good camps and Evil advances - much to my regret, my bows didn't kill anyone.

Turn 3: Priority Good, given to Evil


Gandalf declared a Heroic Channeling (1/3M) and cast Sorcerous Blast (free Will) on one of the Captains. The Captain got a 1 on the resist test, went Prone, and wasn't wounded.

Turn 4: Priority Evil


Gandalf cast another Sorcerous Blast (2/6W) on a different Captain with a 5-high, who also got a 1 to resist (1/1W). He also went Prone and was unwounded. Once again . . . my archery did nothing.

Turn 5: Priority Good


I called Look to the Sun and Gandalf cast another Sorcerous Blast (4/6W), got a 6-hogh, and a third Captain failed to resist on a 1 (1/1W), went Prone, and wasn't wounded. 


There were a bunch of Heroic Combats from Eomer (free), Gandalf (2/3M), and three of the Uruk-Hai Captains (1/2M). Two of the Uruk-Hai Captains won and killed their foes, while the third lost on a 4-high. Eomer had to boost to win his fight (1/3M) and only killed the enemy Captain he was fighting (so it was an unsuccessful Combat, but he killed a Captain who joined Eomer's fight). Gandalf and the Uber-Captain escalated with Gandalf winning (3/3M, Captain 1/2M) and Gandalf only dealt 2 Wounds to the Uber-Captain, who passed his Fate Save (1/3H, 1/1F).


The rest of the fights traded pretty equally - but since I have a much smaller army, I was kind of wanted to get more out of the Look to the Sun turn. Oh well . . .

Turn 6: Priority Good


Gandalf threw a Transfix on a Captain (5/6W) on a 5-high. I charged who I could and then watched the wave of Uruk-Hai run all over my army. I did get a throwing spears kill on the charge, so that was good.


Eomer called a Combat for free, escalated to win (2/3M, 2/2M for the Captain he was fighting), and proceeded to deal . . . 1 Wound to the Captain, who of course passed his Fate save (1/1F). Overall, I traded equally again . . . which means I am rapidly running out of guys!

Turn 7: Priority Evil, given to Good


Centaur was being kind here in giving me priority, but I think he benefitted a lot from getting to respond to my movement - look at all the traps! Gandalf cast Transfix on the final Captain with Might on a 4+ and - you guessed it - that Captain joined the others with a resist roll of 1. :-) A throwing spears killed a pikeman, which was great.


Eomer and a Captain called Combats (2/2M) - the Uruk-Hai Captain killed his man while Eomer could only finish off the Captain he was fighting. Not good at all . . .


Gandalf wounded a Captain, but only once. The Fate save failed (1/1F, 1/2H). 

Turn 8: Priority tied, Good


Eomer killed a pikeman with his throwing spear


Eomer called a free Heroic Combat but only killed two of the three shield guys he was fighting. Gandalf finished the Captain he was fighting, but now my heroes are the only ones left.

Turn 9: Priority Good


I got lucky and Centaur failed five Courage tests to pile into Gandalf. Other than that, I am well and truly trapped.


Aaaaaand Eomer pulls a diva move and gets a 4-high and dies to the collosal number of wounding dice that he faces.

Turn 10: Priority Evil


Well, one guy failed to charge Gandalf, but there are plenty of guys in the fight . . .


. . . and Gandalf gets a 5-high and dies as well. Oof.

Conclusion 

I will say that this did feel closer than the Fantasy Fellowship run, where good has twice as many heroes and warriors (4 and 24 instead of 2 and 14) and Evil has nearly half as many heroes and warriors (3 and 30 instead of 5 and 42). The game came down to what it usually does against Uruk-Hai: can you grind up the hero when they stop rolling 6s. Today, the Uruk-Hai did and that was that.

We only have one more scenario remaining and it's the subject of THRO 2026: the Battle of Helm's Deep mega scenario! We'll be back to finish the tale sometime next year, but until next time, happy hobbying!

No comments:

Post a Comment