First Impressions: The Kingdoms of Men, Part IV

Good morning gamers,

Tiberius: Red Jacket is back with a review of his beloved Rohan heroes. There will be one point of cross-over with my post on the new War of the Rohirrim heroes, but this should cover all of the previous Rohan heroes who didn't make their way into the undying lands of the Legacies document and the not-so-undying-lands of the greatly-anticipated Armies of Middle-Earth supplement. Forth Eorlingas!

* * *

Red Jacket: Today we are going to examine the profile updates for some of the new edition’s Rohan faction.  Specifically, we are looking at the profiles that carried over from the 2018 Edition Armies book and supplements. This article does not review the new profiles introduced in the 2024 edition… as if there weren’t enough Rohan heroes already. Nor will it comment on the tragi… I mean… “necessary” removal of some of the heroes that weren’t featured in the film. (Even though at least one of them was.) (Yes I know there is another book coming.)

Despite that angsty intro, I like most of the actual changes made to the profiles. I have just a couple more housekeeping things to comment on before diving in.

First, as you are no doubt aware, all profiles had an intelligence stat added in the new edition. I won’t be commenting on it much, since this is a compare and contrast article. Second, all profiles switched to hand weapons, and removed special strikes. I will only be commenting on this in as much as I feel it truly impacts how the model regularly interacts with the game on the tabletop. Finally, in the case of heroes, I will not be commenting on heroic tiers. While in the old edition, they were fixed (more or less) and were a significant aspect of the profile and hero choice in list building, that is not the case in the new edition, with tier being dependent upon the list they are taken in.

So without further ado, let’s take a look at these new profiles.

 

Battle Report: The Three Trolls v. Muster of Isengard

Hey Reader!

In a stunning turn of events, we are back with ANOTHER BATTLE REPORT! I hope to get a lot more battle report content out on the blog this year, because writing battle reports has been fun, and I've missed it, so hopefully you'll be seeing more coming down the pike soon! :)

We decided to do a 600pt match today; Tiberius will be fielding his Muster of Isengard list (Saruman is BACK baby!), while I will be playing The Three Trolls, because monsters! And also this list is wildly different from the previous edition, so I figured it's worth taking them out for a spin (since I don't think I ever got to use them in the last edition thanks to the whole 400pts thing)!

Army lists are below:

Tiberius's List: Muster of Isengard

Warband 1

Saruman (Army Leader)

7 Uruk-Hai Warriors with pikes 

6 Uruk-Hai Warriors with shields 

2 Uruk-Hai Berserkers 

3 Uruk-Hai Scouts with Uruk-Hai bows

Warband 2

Uruk-Hai Captain

1 Uruk-Hai Warrior with banner 

2 Uruk-Hai Warriors with pikes

3 Uruk-Hai Berserkers 

6 Uruk-Hai Scouts with Uruk-Hai bows

Enemy Warband

Grima Wormtongue

TOTAL: 600pts, 33 models, 5 Might, 1 DOPE CASTER

Centaur's List: The Three Trolls

Warband 1

Bill the Troll (Army Leader)

Warband 2

Bert the Troll

Warband 3

Tom the Troll

Troll Hoard: 

Nothing Like a Warm Fire (Campfire Banner/Resistant to Magic/Courage effects are increased from 6" to 18")

Full Bellies (All trolls start with 3M / 3W / 3F)

Bowl 'Em Over (Trolls may use their throwing stones as throwing weapons, and may reroll their Hurl distance)

Cover of Darkness (the game will be played at night, and the trolls gain Cave Dweller)

TOTAL: 600pts, 3 models, 9 Might

First Impressions: Misty Mountains, Part I (and a Sneaky Top 10 Ranking Post)

Hey Reader!

Welcome back! We're back reviewing more of the armies from the new edition, and today we're looking at the 3 profiles tied to The Three Trolls. This army was hard to use in the last edition, both because of a restrictive alliance matrix (all of which required you to lose your army bonus), but also because they only had like 400pts worth of units total in the list. So if you were playing at higher points levels, you were forced to ally if you didn't want to give your opponent a huge advantage.

But those days are over: now in the new edition this army plays at high points levels as well! So we'll jump into how the units have changed, how the army special rules have changed (as they finally have a legendary legion of sorts), and how their points scale at higher points levels without adding warrior options.

First Impressions: The Elven Kingdoms, Part I

Good morning gamers,

I know I've said this a bajillion times before, but when I got started playing MESBG back in 2010 (during the Legions of Middle-Earth era and when it was called LOTR SBG), the first warrior pack I got for the Forces of Good was Wood Elf Warriors. I opened it minutes before opening the Dwarf Warrior pack, which quickly became a favorite of mine and a bane to the other guys starting to play the game with me, but it was my Wood Elf Warriors that eventually defined one of my favorite play styles: everyone shoots and if we get caught, we die. Over the years, I've collected Galadhrim (on foot and mounted) and have amassed most of the heroes, but with a new edition of the game, I can safely say that I both know how Lothlorien should be played . . . and honestly admit that I have no idea what I'm doing with them at the moment. :) They've both changed and not changed - I promise this makes sense, let's make some sense of that, shall we?

Lothlorien: How Have They Changed?

So we need to start out by addressing that there are some profiles that have left the Lothlorien list at this juncture and should arrive in the Armies of Middle-Earth supplement (since they didn't appear in the list of profiles being sent to Legacies):

• Combat Celeborn (wait, isn't that the only Celeborn? Why no, no it's not - keep reading);
• Orophin;
• Rumil;
• Galadhrim Knights (and mounted Galadhrim Captains);
• Guards of the Galadhrim Court; and
• Wood Elf Sentinels

This . . . doesn't leave us with much, but there are some cool new toys in real old packages that we have to play with now. Let's start off with . . .

Photo Credit: Tenor.com

Galadriel got 5pts cheaper and . . . pretty much stayed the same - at least as far as her stats and rules are concerned. She's still unarmed with a bad number of Attacks and a low Strength stat, but she's still F6, so with some help, she can win very, very managed fights. She still gets a free Will point each turn and can take her mirror (which is now on a 40mm base - something I need to hobby up so I can play with her soon!).

But there were some big changes to her special rules. First off, the Mirror of Galadriel not only allows a friendly hero during each End Phase within 6" of the Mirror to regain all their previously-lost Fate points, but if either Galadriel or Celeborn is in base contact with the Mirror, you can get a +1 bonus to your Priority roll . . . that's NUTS (and makes the 25pt investment very, VERY much worth it). Second, Galadriel's spell suite changed quite a bit. She has <check the list - it looks wrong>. All in all, very much the same profile - but now with some new tricks.